1. This article will
appear in a longer version, with full sections on "The Perverse Humour of
the Infantile Vidûshaka: Psychoanalysis, Criminal Law and Sacrificial
Dharma" (discussing at length the Sanskrit drama, Mrcchakatikâ) and
"The Infanticide Ankâlamman: The Termite-Mound of the Untouchable
Cempatavars and the Royal Obstetrics in the Cremation-ground," in Sunthar
and Elizabeth Visuvalingam, Transgressive Sacrality in the Hindu Tradition, (= TSHT) TS Series vol.1 (Cambridge: Rudra
Press, 1989). Materials on the Vidûshaka and the cult of Ankâlamman have been
condensed for this volume due to lack of space.
2.
For an elementary
introduction to the subject, see my "Transgressive Sacrality in the Hindu
Tradition: As a basis of inter-religious dialogue, the ethical problem it
poses, and its symbolic communication through the buffoon of the Sanskrit
drama," originally presented to the Assembly of the World's Religions,
15-21 November 1985 (New York), before serving as the prospectus for the
pilot-conference on this problematic within the 15th Annual Conference on
South-Asia, Univ. of Wisconsin, 8 November 1986 (Madison). It is appearing in TSHT (see n.1) and also in Serbo-Croat in Kulture Istoka, 5, No.17 (Belgrade: July-September, 1988). I
am indebted to Alf Hiltebeitel not only for having presided but also for
resituating the proceedings of his own "Criminal gods and Demon
devotees" conference within what I regard to be the more fundamental,
global and immediate problem of Transgressive Sacrality.
3.
Abhinavagupta,
citing his relative Vâmanagupta, on the semblance of humor and of sorrow in Abhinavabhâratî.
4.
For the
continuity between Pâshupata and Kâpâlika praxis, see E. Visuvalingam's section
in this volume on "The Transgressive Fifth Head of Brahmâ and the
Pâshupata Ultimate Weapon" (esp. nn.16 and 60-62).
5.
See M. Eliade,
Shamanism: Archaic
Techniques of Ecstasy (New
Jersey: Princeton University Press, 1964), pp.xi, 15, 20, 23-32, 365n.
6.
S. Kramrisch, The Presence of Shiva (Delhi: Oxford University Press. 1981),
pp.159; see n.22 of E. Visuvalingam's rendering of "The Origin-Myth of
Bhairava" in this volume.
7.
For the
distinction between ‘sacred’ and the repressed ‘profane’ laughter in Amerindian
religion, see Lévi-Strauss, "Suppressed Laughter," in The Raw and the Cooked, Introduction
to a Science of Mythology: vol.1 (1970; Penguin, 1986), pp.109, 120-132, which also provides evidence,
overlooked by Lévi-Strauss himself, of not only comic behavior but also
tickling serving as symbolic substitutes for transgression in mythology.
Otherwise devalorized, (sacred) laughter is nevertheless credited, in myth 45,
with the origin of language itself (p.123, cf. p.132).
8. L. Renou, Religions of Ancient
India (London: Univ. of
London Athlone Press, 1953), p.10, 18; also L'Inde fondamentale, ed. C. Malamoud (Paris: Hermann, 1978),
pp.11-80.
9.
See G. Dumézil, Mitra-Varuna, 2nd ed. (Paris: Gallimard,1948), and
especially my treatment of the Gândharva musical symbolism in the Vidûshaka
Maitreya and the criminal Shakâra in the Mrcchakatikâ (see n.1).
10.
See L. Makarius,
"Ritual Clowns and Symbolic Behavior," Diogenes no.69 (Spring 1970).
11.
See M. Detienne,
"Dionysos orphique et le
bouilli rôti," in Dionysos mis à mort (Paris: Gallimard, 1977), pp.163-217; also
W. Burkert, Homo
Necans: The Anthropology of Ancient Greek Sacrificial Ritual and Myth (Berkeley: Univ. of California Press, 1983),
pp.89 n.29, 105, 119, 122-5, 177-8. Cf. J.C. Heesterman's key-note paper on
"The Vedic origin of Vegetarianism," delivered to the 15th South-Asia
Conference (see n.1) along with his contribution there to the Transgressive
Sacrality seminar on "The Notion of Anthropophagy in Vedic Ritual"
centered on the consumption of the Dionysian dîkshita reduced (nowadays) to a he-goat.
12.
See D. Lorenzen
in this volume and especially E. Visuvalingam's section in this volume on
"The Kâpâlika-Bhairava: The Supreme Penance of the Criminal Dîkshita."
13.
See A. Sanderson,
"Purity and Power among the Brahmans of Kashmir" in M. Carrithers et
al eds., The
Category of the Person: Anthropology, Philosophy, History (Cambridge: Cambridge Univ. Press, 1986),
pp.190-216; and "Mandala and Agamic Identity in the Trika of
Kashmir," Mantras et Diagrammes Rituels dans l'Hindouisme (Paris: CNRS,1986) pp.169-214.
14.
This is also the
gist of J.-P. Vernant's treatment of "The Pure and the Impure," in Myth and Society in
Ancient Greece (Sussex:
Harvester Press, and New Jersey: Humanities Press, 1980), pp.110-29.
15.
See J. Parry,
"Ghosts, Greed and Sin: The Occupational Identity of the Benares Funeral
Priests," in Man (NS) 15 (1980), pp.88-111; "Sacrificial death and
the necrophagous ascetic," in M. Bloch and J.P. Parry eds., Death and the
Regeneration of Life
(Cambridge: Cambridge Univ. Press,1982), and esp. E. Visuvalingam's section in
this volume on "The Sin-Eating Bhairava: Death and Embryogony in
Kâsî" (also n.116).
16. See J. Gonda, Notes on Brahman (Utrecht: J.L.Beyers,1950), pp.16-18, 57-61;
and especially L. Renou (and L. Silburn), "Sur la notion bráhman" in L'Inde fondamentale, pp.83-116 (see n.8).
17.
See L. Makarius, Le Sacré et la Violation des Interdits (Paris: Payot,1974), p.311; C. Lévi-Strauss, Anthropologie
Structurale, vol.2 (Paris:
Plon,1973), pp.32-34, and Le Regard Eloigné (Paris: Plon,1983), pp.301-18; with the
criticisms of Makarius, Structuralisme ou Ethnologie: Pour une critique
radicale de l'anthropologie de Lévi-Strauss (Paris: Anthropos,1973), pp.16-19. See esp. E.
Visuvalingam, n.4 above.
18.
See my Ph.D.
thesis (1983) on Abhinavagupta's Bisociative Conception of Humor: Its Resonances in
Indian Aesthetics, Transgressive Sacrality and Contemporary Indology (1988).